NTPC
CMP: Rs 208
BSE Code: 532555
Face Value: Rs 10
Div Yield (%): 1.73
With 30,644 MW capacities (around 30 per cent of generation capacity of India) NTPC is the undisputed leader in the industry. But apart from its leadership position there are certain other factors which merit recommendation of NTPC as one of our buys. Its ability of running those capacities at commendable efficiency levels is difficult for its peers to replicate. Further, its recent multi-pronged strategy to counter fuel constraints, expected divestment by March 2010, consistent dividend payment and expected improvement in the earnings due to new CERC guidelines are some of the additional factors.
Further, on the valuation front also, the scrip is well-placed. The CMP of Rs 208 discounts its trailing four quarter earnings by 19.70x (EPS Rs 10.56) and its EV/EBITDA stands at 17.80x. Even its price to book ratio of 2.70x also seems to be well-placed against 8x of Adani Power and 3.65x of Tata Power Company. Further, its EV/MW of Rs 6.32 crore is only next to Rs 5.74 crore of CESC.
We recommend the investors to buy the scrip at current levels with a target price of Rs 270 in next one year. One should also have the scrip in the portfolio to provide stability to the portfolio.
NTPC is leader in power generation and with is aggressive capacity addition it will be able to maintain its position. With 2800 MW to be added in H2FY10, 4460 MW in FY11 (2460 standalone + 2000 JV) and 4940 MW (3690 + 1250) in FY12 it is expected to maintain its growth trajectory. There were some project delay concerns, but we feel those have been already factored in. Total capex is estimated at Rs 62,800 crore and will be funded through internal accruals and loans from institutions.
As mentioned earlier, its PLF has been very good (82.60 per cent) in FY09. It has been better in H1FY10 (83 per cent) as compared to H1FY09 (75.10 per cent, due to lower gas availability). Going ahead, the PLF is expected to be better as the company is applying multi-pronged strategy where it is looking for coal supply agreements, global acquisition of mining assets, development of captive mines and gas linkages.
On the financial front, after posting better than expected results in FY09, it has carried the momentum in the H1FY10 also. Driven by the volume growth it posted a total income of Rs 24,302.80 crore and bottomline of Rs 4,345.60 crore as compared to Rs 19,142.50 crore and Rs 3,837 crore respectively in H1FY09. Going ahead, we expect the revenue growth to continue with additional capacity additions. The consensus estimates for FY10 stand at Rs 50,176 crore and bottomline of Rs 8,873 crore resulting in EPS of Rs 10.75 and P/E of 19.16x. Putting all these factors together we recommend the investors to buy the scrip at current levels with a target price of Rs 270.
[PAGE BREAK]
Rane Madras
CMP: Rs 69
BSE Code: 532661
Face Value: Rs 10
Div Yield (%): NA
Rane Madras is a flagship company of Rane Group and is engaged in the manufacture of auto components. It manufacturers automotive components like steering linkages, ball joints, axial joints, suspension joints and manual steering gears for every segment of automobile industry, including passenger cars, multi utility vehicles, commercial vehicles and farm tractors. The company serves clients such as Tata Nano, Piaggio, Mahindra SCV, etc. It also has strategic partnership with various companies around world for technical assistance. The manufacturing facility of the company is located in the southern part of India, except the one at Uttarakhand, which caters to the customer of northern part of India. The economic slowdown and disinclination of banks’ to lend for purchasing cars, trucks, etc. had severely dented the auto sales last year. But proactive action by different governments like slew of tax cuts and reduction in the loan rates helped spur the auto sales this fiscal. For example, India’s largest car maker, Maruti Suzuki India reported 66.57 per cent jump in its total sales at 87,807 units during November. Even Hyundai Motor’s total sales for November, 2009 stood at an all-time high of 55,265 units against 43,020 units in November last year. Even internationally, auto sales are improving and on adjusted and annualized basis the U.S. auto market posted sales of 11 million units in November compared to 10.4 million a year ago. All these improving conditions augur well for the company as its fortune is very much linked to improving auto sales, albeit will some lag effect. All this is reflected even in the company’s sales for the quarter ending September 2009, although the company’s revenue dropped by two per cent and was Rs 99.10 crore on yearly basis, it was mainly because of decline in replacement market by four per cent. Part of this fall was contained by domestic jump in original equipment market, which grew by seven per cent on annual basis. Nevertheless, the bottomline of the company saw good improvement and turned into black. The company recorded profit of Rs 3.3 crore against loss of Rs 0.42 crore last year same quarter. This better performance was achieved due to better cost control by company, which managed to bring down the cost from 96 per cent of sales in Q2FY09 to 92 per cent in Q2FY10. The icing on the cake is the lower valuation at which the scrip is avail-able. The current market price of company’s share discounts its earning of last 12 months by 13 times, which looks cheap compared to its peers. When we look at company’s market cap to sales, it is 0.19 times of FY09 sales which again is on the lower side. We feel that, going forward, with the improvement in external environment, the company will improve its financial performance. Hence, we suggest investors to invest in the counter with 12-18 months time horizon.
[PAGE BREAK]
Spice Mobiles
CMP: Rs 31.50
BSE Code: 517214
Face Value: Rs 3
Div Yield (%): 1
Justifying the middle letter of its name Spice i.e ‘i’ which stands for innovation, Spice Mobiles (SPL) has the distinction of delivering various firsts to the Indian mobile industry such as providing dual SIM series across GSM and CDMA, the world’s first movie phone etc. SPL is a part of USD 1.5 billion B K Modi Spice Group and is engaged in the manufacturing and selling of mobile handsets. During the 15 months ending March 31, 2009, SPL has sold more than 2.7 million handsets and the current business environment provides an excellent opportunity for the company to exploit its competitive advantage. Though the company’s product portfolio is present in the entire segment of mobile sets, including monochrome, colour, CDMA etc, SPL’s competitive advantage lies in its low price and entry level mobiles that offer value for money. To exploit this opportunity the company has again added one more first to its credit and launched the world’s first people’s phone for less than USD 20, which in rupee terms is below Rs 1,000. This will help the company in riding at the bottom of the pyramid. With rural teledensity just 19 per cent at the end of September 2009 - one of the lowest among Asian countries, including Pakistan - and call rates already one of the lowest in the world, the situation augurs well to spur the demand for mobile phones across the country. To take advantage of the current situation, SPL has already committed investment of Rs 100 crore. This fund will be used at its Baddi facility to expand and extend its manufacturing facility since it is also used to produce other devices. Once this facility is ready, as expected by March 2011, it will have the capacity of producing 2 million mobile units a month. That apart, the roll-out of 3G services will help drive the sales of SPL’s 3G-enabled mobile handsets. SPL’s financial performance stands testimony to the company’s improving conditions. In the first half of FY10 the company’s profit increased by 4.68 times whereas its sales increased a shade below 60 per cent. What is heartening is that the company’s earning per share (EPS) has been increasing on a quarter-on-quarter basis since September 2008 and this has helped in the company witnessing a complete turnaround. In September 2008 the company had posted loss of 84 paise per share whereas in the latest quarter it recorded a profit of Rs 2.2 per share. Despite demonstrating such stellar growth the company is available at just 7.5 times of its last 12-month earnings. The market cap to sales of the company too is as low as 0.31 times. Further, adding strength to its balance sheet is SPL’s low debt equity which at the end of FY09 was 0.02 times. Even the EV/EBIDTA of the company stands at 4.28 times and this certainly looks attractive. Looking at the company’s growth prospects and its cheap valuation our suggestion is that you should pick up Spice Mobiles
[PAGE BREAK]
SRF
CMP: Rs 192
BSE Code: 503806
Face Value: Rs 10
Div Yield (%): 3
SRF is into business of technical textiles, refrigerants, engineering plastics, industrial yarn and pack-aging films and the flagship company of Bharat Ram group is again featuring on buy list after we recommended during Muhurat buys.
Last time, our recommendation was based on its first quarter numbers that showed robust recovery and has given very positive indication for coming quarters. The company has continued its better performance even in the second quarter. Due to that company achieved almost same net profit in first six months of current year that it had achieved in the last full year. But there is one more positive indication that indicates that company is heading towards better future. The company declared Rs 7 per share interim dividend against last year’s full year dividend of Rs 5 per share. This makes us believe that company is on strong footing. Putting forward these good numbers Ashish Bharat Ram, MD, SRF, quipped; “Unlike in the past, the profit growth this time has come from a better performance of the technical textiles business. This is extremely heartening to see and we hope the trend will continue in the future. In addition, with our capex coming on line, we hope to see a higher increase in our topline as well.” Going forward, the company plans to invest Rs 600 crore in the coming one to two years for the expansion of various businesses. From this amount, Rs 57 crore has been earmarked for establishing laminated fabric plant at Kashipur. Also, expansion of tyre chord plant at Gumidipoondi, Tamil Nadu, is being done at a cost of Rs 186 crore to accommodate polyester industrial yarn (PIY). This capacity will start generating revenue at its full capacity by next financial year. The company is also investing Rs 30 crore into fluorospeciality business, which will have an initial capacity of 400 tonnes and Rs 165 crore would be invested for Bopet Line II for the expansion of packaging films business. The company’s export business is also showing signs of recovery on the heels of global recovery. A point worth noting is that 80 per cent volume of refrigerants business comes from export to 45 countries. The price fluctuations have also subsided as far as finished products are concerned. The company has netted an operating profit margin of 35.94 per cent and 28.84 per cent in the first quarter and second quarter respectively, quite high in comparison to March ’09 (7.46%) and December ’08 (22.79%). Currently, the company’s scrip is trading at trailing P/E of 5 at Rs 192. The company’s EV/EBIDTA is 4.37x giving a good valuation to the company. On the first half year’s performance basis in 2009-10, the company is expected to earn PAT of Rs. 300 crore, which translates into EPS of Rs. 49.59, much ahead of Rs 26.91 in 2008-09. Another angle to the financials of the company is that it is entitled to claim 3.8 million carbon credits annually and this will be available for the company at least till December 2012 but may go up till 2014. Quantitatively value of these credits depends on the euro/rupee exchange rate. All these factors make this a value buy in 2010.
[PAGE BREAK]
Tata Elxsi
CMP: Rs 239
BSE Code: 500408
Face Value: Rs 10
Div Yield (%): 2.3
Despite the fact that there are a host of IT companies for the taking, we have decided to take a different route and place our bet on Tata Elxsi once again as we believe this scrip has the potential to deliver the goods for the investors in the year 2010. Previously there were factors such as consistent performance, dividends, high dividend yield etc which made us like this company and hence it was recommended during the year 2009. But this time there are a couple of additional factors along with the existing ones which have made it even more attractive. TEL’s business is basically divided into two segments, viz. software development and services which con-tribute 90 per cent to total revenues and system integration and support services which brings in the balance 10 per cent. The company’s revenues are well-spread globally and in a bid to generate growth more briskly it is now strengthening its worldwide presence further. The first step that it has taken towards fulfilling this objective is to set up a brand new visual FX studio in Los Angeles. By doing so the company wants to tap the cream or high-end visual FX projects of Hollywood where the margins are bet-ter. It should be noted that the visual FX outsourced to India are basically mid-end jobs. But by opening a new studio in LA, the company is aiming to grab the big ones which will lend top speed to its revenue growth. The company is aiming at opening more such studios in high growth markets. In fact, Madhukar Dev, CEO, Tata Elxsi recently said that TEL expects to get USD 300-400 million in topline over the next three years. This translates into Rs 1,860 crore over the next three years. If that was not enough, TEL is also exploring opportunities in wimax and 3G, where it could provide the software needed to run the telecom base stations and also design content for multimedia content providers. TEL is already in talks with several telecom companies. This would further help augment its revenues, but it’s too early to name a figure. That apart, TEL has de-risked its revenue model with the US, the UK and Japan, each generating 30 per cent of the total revenues. TEL has been consistently paying dividends since the past nine years with a dividend yield of 3 per cent. It is also low on debt. On the financial front, TEL’s FY09 revenues and profits stand at Rs 418 crore and Rs 58.11 crore respectively. However, H1FY10 has been tough for TEL with revenues at Rs 181 crore and profits at Rs 19.93 crore, indicating a dip of 12 per cent each. Thus, on a conservative basis and assuming similar performance for H2FY10, TEL is available at a PE of over 18x at its FY10 earnings’ estimate. But if we consider TEL management’s estimates for the next three years, for FY11 TEL could at least generate estimated revenues of Rs 620 crore and profits of Rs 87 crore. At these estimates TEL is available at a PE of just 8x, which certainly makes it worth it since it provides room for upward movement. We therefore put a ‘buy’ on Tata Elxsi with a one year price target of Rs 360.
[PAGE BREAK]
High Inflation Can Spook The Markets
The amount of money printing that went on simply acted as a medicine, but the recession never went away. So when the benign cycle of low rates and low inflation reverses, high inflation will take its toll on the markets
We have an overall negative view on global equities for 2010. It is our belief that the year ahead offers severe challenges and that we have had only a temporary relief from a very troublesome situation.
Let’s put the world in context. Till 2007, the world grew well, based on two main factors: first, a depreciating US dollar that drove out capital from the US into emerging markets, and second, a credit explosion worldwide, fuelled by ultra-low interest rates. Quite strangely, these two factors didn’t cause any inflation at all, which led to monetary policy remaining loose for a long period of time, further exacerbating the excesses.
All that reached a point of no return in the summer of 2007, and from thereon, the great unraveling began.
This went on till March 2009. And then, seemingly, the Great Recession went away, almost like a bad memory. Markets globally went up 50-100 per cent. The recession was all but forgot-ten. That countries had gone to the brink of bankruptcy was forgotten.
But all this never went away. What happened was simply that the amount of money printing that went on, simply acted as a strong medicine. That medicine made the symptoms disappear, causing most to believe that the root cause had gone away. And that the medicine would have no side-effects.
Fact is: There can’t be medicine this strong without side-effects…and in a monetary sense, this is will show up in the form of high inflation.
Mind you: global inflation may well remain subdued, but emerging markets including India, where food comprises a very large part of the inflation basket, we will see skyrocketing inflation.
This will be because of two things: one, the effect of the low inflation base that has prevailed in 2009; two, sharply rising prices of agri-commodities like wheat, rice, etc, worldwide.
What this will do is to reverse the whole benign cycle that prevailed throughout 2009 of low rates and low inflation. Both these factors will reverse over the next few months.
We remain negative on global equities, and see a 20 per cent downside at least, including in India.
Overall, we see 2010 as being a generally troublesome year for equities, and would advise remaining underweight/underinvested in equities to the retail investor.
[PAGE BREAK]
Market Reasonably Valued At 16000-17000
The umbilical relationship between economy and markets would refl ect in the strong earnings of businesses, stock prices and returns
My view for the next 3-5 years is that the economy is going to grow aggressively and it has got be reflected into the markets because there is an umbilical cord kind of relationship between size of the economy and size of markets. In turn, it has got to reflect in the earnings of the businesses, the prices and hence the returns. I am sure that next 3-5 years will produce a very strong performance for economy as well as the markets. I believe that the economy will continue to grow at above average rate for a very long period of time. We are looking at an opportunity where it may happen for 15-20 years of so and to that extent Indian economy and in turn Indian markets represent a great opportunity. I feel that we are in a structural long term buy.
The next year, from a corporate earning point of view, we will grow at a rate much faster rate than what it has been for the current year. I would think that markets are fairly priced So come next year, if earnings fair nicely, there is a fair chance that markets will logically reflect a portion of that increase. To that extent, I would have positive stance on that. I remain very positive on the secular long term rise of Indian markets.
The year 2009 has shown clearly that this economy has in-built inherent strength of its kind which provides resilience. It has good capital efficiency, especially the corporate sector, which is well-balanced. You have 55-56 per cent of GDP by way of services, 29-30 per cent by way of industry and manufacturing, and the remaining by way of agriculture, so it’s a well balanced economy. The fact that it is a significantly domestic economy – 80 per cent domestic, 20 per cent exports – shows the strength of the economy and that it can sustain itself on its own for a considerable length of time. We have witnessed this in the banking sector also. While most of the global banks have been going through crisis, Indian banks had the best two quarters, the balance sheets have been strong, return on equity has been favourable, and profit growth has been strong.
Secondly, the destruction witnessed for most part of 2008 and early 2009 was overdone. This is not to contend that when the markets were at 21,000 they were not overvalued, but at the same time they didn’t deserve to go down to 7500. If 21,000 were on the higher side, 7,500 was the other ultimate extreme. Once rationality was restored, the markets rebound. But markets have already shot up very sharply from 7500 levels from an undeserving low base. It was perversely pushed down to that level and it rebounded very strongly. In my view, the markets are reasonably valued around 16000-17000 levels so its kind of struggling around that level but it is kind of nicely consolidating here, it is not showing weakness.
I have a long view on the markets for the next 5-10 years and I am sure the markets will sustain. It could be upwards of 20000-30000-40000-50000. But this is no rocket science, if the GDP is going to grow at about 8-8.5 percent for the next 15-20 years then corporate earnings are bound to grow at 16-25 per cent which is 2-3 times and if that is going to happen in such a market and I am sure in the long run will compound definitely between 15-20 per cent.
[PAGE BREAK]
But I think the Indian markets have not gone up the way other markets have gone up. Look at the car sales, two-wheeler sales, increase in telecom subscriber base, consumer businesses’ performance. Most of the FMCG seems to be in a robust shape in terms of their volumes etc. In general if you look at hotels/ restaurants they are full and doing good business. So the consumption is intact, the savings portion of the economy is intact at about 37-38 per cent of GDP. What has taken a bit of a setback is investment demand, but now even that is coming back partly because of government efforts of putting money behind infrastructure projects.
Thirdly, I would say that Indian corporate sector has to be appreciated as it has quickly turned around. With rupee going haywire, raw material prices going haywire and huge inventories piling up, how quickly our corporate mastered these factors and overcame them is commendable. The government did the right thing in terms of providing the stimulus and backing it up, thereby giving confidence.
As far as the internal dynamics are concerned I would say we are out of the worst and we are reasonably comfortable as to the way the things are and we can assume that things have gotten back into shape. As far as external is concerned, I think it will be hard to assume that Europe and Japan’s problems are over. To that extent, that portion of Indian economy that is dependent on the external world for some amount of consumption, businesses will have to factor that.
As for sectors, I have a view beyond 2010. Banking and finance is always a lead indicator, infrastructure related businesses represents a great opportunity. Consumer business is a sound business, energy and related business are hugely attractive given the fact that there is a shortfall of demand and supply. I think India’s strength in pharma is very strong and given the chemistry strength and matured business there is a huge opportunity. I also believe automobile is going to do well and in 10-15 years India will storm the global automobile scenario, not only in engineering but also design and manufacture. I would also think that software business is good. Many of these companies have shown resistance in bad markets.
I would think investing is a simple business and we should not make it complicated by making too many assumptions. If we are able to forecast that business will get bigger tomorrow even if we maintain if not improve their efficiency, then they should be good. Broadly, what you need to get right is you get into right business and not mediocre ones.
[PAGE BREAK]
2010: The Year Of The Intrepid Investor
Led by high beta sectors like metals, infrastructure, banking and real estate, not to forget the expectation of a 7 per cent growth in Indian economy, the year 2010 may test new highs and this may well put the value investors in a quandary
2009 was perhaps a year of missed opportunities for many. Everyone waited for a ‘correction’ that never happened. Markets have a habit of not conforming to expectations, thus levelling all so-called ‘experts’ to the dust. In a year when the globe went through considerable pain, the stock markets were on a high. For those who did not listen to reason or those who chose to remain long-term investors, the rewards were ample. Our stock markets delivered handsome returns, but with much narrower participation as the FII inflows surged in and absorbed the thin floating stock in the markets. Perhaps they had faith, which the locals did not exhibit!
2010 is a year that is perhaps likely to confound the ‘value’ investor yet again. As I write this, the markets are at a level that no one considers ‘cheap’. So, there is one pocket waiting for a correction. There is one other section of people (with money to back) who say that Indian economy is growing at nearly 7 per cent and the globe will perhaps grow at one-fourth the pace. So, I want to be in Indian equities, which look far more attractive, with a lot of growth stored in them.
We start 2010 with the expectation that:
a) Globally, interest rates can only go up
b) The central government bail-outs will happen, albeit selectively
c) The mighty US dollar is slipping from its perch, with no substitute in sight
d) As a corollary, gold is fashionable once more
e) Oil prices will move up once the US sets course on a growth path
f) Indian industry is hale and hearty, with profitability set to expand
g) Corporate governance surprises a la Satyam can happen
h) Government will continue with its profligacy with fiscal deficits of a high order
i) Tax tinkering may happen such as hike in service tax, withdrawal of some corporate freebies etc
j) Vote bank economics in the garb of ‘aam aadmi’ will continue, and
k) FII flows will not get taxed in spite of reasons for doing so.
So, going by the above, I would expect the markets to test new highs in 2010. There is also a strong possibility that this could happen as early as the first half of calendar 2010. With floating stock managed very well and a full IPO pipeline, a bullish market is on the cards. The Indian economy is expected to post growth of more than 7 per cent in 2010-11. Of course the government numbers would be higher. Agriculture is still a question mark. However, the services’ sector, which is now in a consolidation phase, should start to look up. There are signs of exports stabilising. Most important, the last year or so has seen some fantastic corporate belt-tightening which should get reflected in higher profitability. Of course, I do not expect profitability to touch the shortage era of 2007-08, but much better than 2008-09.
[PAGE BREAK]
Inflation will perhaps wait for a year, as the existing world supply has to meet only a truncated demand across the globe as compared to 2007. This time I expect the market to be led higher by the high beta sectors like metals, infrastructure, banking and real estate. The so called ‘defensive’ sectors like FMCG will continue to remain so and will spike during phases of market volatility and uncertainty. PSU banks have masked their ill-health with regulatory support on funny accounting and markets do not have the wherewithal or patience to dig deeper and will take the story at face value. Use any spike in prices to junk them on to the believers.
Another key thing I will do is to keep a sharp eye on the timing of the new high. If it happens in the first quarter or thereabouts, get the hell out of stocks. You would probably have got the full year’s rewards in a short time. However, if the markets continue to take three steps ahead, two back and then breathe, it will be tough to make money if you are a trader. So, I think the key will be to get in early and wait it out. With the world awash in liquidity created by the excesses of government printing presses, the Indian bourses offer very tempting parking space. The recipe is right for an upward surge. 2010 is NOT a year for those who are going to seek value. Those who chase growth will perhaps ride the roller-coaster in store for 2010. It would pay to get in early.
[PAGE BREAK]
Infrastructure Spending Will Boost Growth
The growth has happened primarily due to government spending, and going forward its thrust on infrastructure sector will provide further boost to the growth
When things go wrong people tend to think that there is no end to the misery. So they all start getting pessimistic about the market. In 2009, that is what happened. People thought that markets will never rise. The reverse happened when markets were going up. People thought that it would never fall.
Now, if you look at the way the EPS is likely to increase, I think markets can touch new highs. This is because the government policies have proved to be very positive. The policies were made with a very gloomy scenario in mind. The main thrust of the policy was to inject liquidity and boost consumption. It was thought that with this, growth will be achieved or de-growth will be arrested. Particularly for India, not only de-growth was arrested, but growth has actually come and surprised everyone. All the experts including international funds all are in the process of revising the GDP forecast for the current year as well as the next year.
The growth that happened was driven primarily by government spending and the liquidity part took care of day-to-day dealing and restoring market confidence. Whether I will achieve growth is one thing but my banking activity won’t be affected. My funds won’t be frozen and if I require money I will get it. That is what has boosted the confidence.
Stimulus package was for a short period, which means it has to end sometime. How and when it has to be ended I think policy makers are in a good position to take that call. Central banks and governments around the world have said that it was a temporary measure and will be withdrawn when the time comes. This is a call each government will take. Maybe, for India it will be shorter, for the USA it would be longer.
It is estimated that the EPS of the Sensex would be around Rs 1,150 and when we are looking at growth everyone says that FY11 growth will be more than FY10 growth.
Our GDP had grown close to 8.8 per cent on an average over the last 5 years. We haven’t seen double digit GDP growth, so what prevents us from desiring this type of growth? But a lot of work needs to be done in terms of investments and activities. Just think of the amount of investments required in the areas of infrastructure! In other words there is tremendous potential.
No doubt we are a domestic driven economy, but in the financial sector it is very much integrated. So if there is anything affecting the world financial system that is going to affect us and there is no doubt on that. But even last year when the world growth was very low, we have been growing at a higher rate. Now from 9 per cent, if it suddenly drops to 7 per cent level, it is not good. Therefore, for our overall development, we need a higher rate of growth.
The government is focusing a lot on infrastructure sector, so naturally it will have a higher growth rate. We can see growth in the automobile space, utilities, telecom, and oil & gas. All these would be outperformers. We see a secular growth across sectors, but FMCG may have a growth at par with the market. Invest for the long-term through systematic investment plans (SIPs).
[PAGE BREAK]
Yet Another Lost Decade?
In the United States, the last ten years have proved to be the lost decade as the S&P has declined by 28 per cent. When adjusted for inflation the numbers are even more discouraging with a decline in excess of 40 per cent. A recent Time magazine cover story argued that the worst was behind us but my research suggests otherwise
A secular bull or bear market is a period in which inflation-adjusted equity prices persistently rise or fall over the course of many business cycles. Chart 1 shows that since 1901 there have been four secular bear markets. The most recent one began in the year 2000 but has yet to run its course. Arguably, the most popular long-term measure of stock market valuation is the price investors are willing to pay for corporate earnings. Why at one time are fearful investors only willing to pay USD 44.20 for that same USD 1 of earnings (i.e. 2000 secular peak)? The answer lies in the extremes of confidence or lack thereof only seen at major secular turning points. The Shiller P/E ratio in the bottom panel of Chart 1 therefore represents an excellent thermometer of investor sentiment.
The most important concept to grasp is that secular trends are a function of long-term mood swings by market participants. In order to begin a new bull market it therefore is necessary for investors to be completely pessimistic about stocks and for the previous generation of bulls to never want to see, hear about or own equities again. Reaching that stage is a difficult thing - to assess from a subjective point of view - but not when we look at an objective measure such as the P/E ratio. In that respect, sentiment was so bearish at the lows of 1920, 1949 and 1982 that the ratio fell back to an average bargain basement reading of 6.95.
Another psychological yardstick is the dividend yield on the S&P. At secular bull market peaks investors are very confident and are therefore willing to give up current income for perceived capital gains. That means they will settle for a relatively low yield below 3 per cent. On the other hand, at bear market lows they are so despondent that only an average 7.1 per cent yield will do. Chart 2 shows that neither the P/E (18) nor the current dividend yield (2.07 per cent) are close to the kind of reading typically seen at secular lows.
Another measure of investor psychological stamina i.e. the ability to take knocks and come out fighting again, comes from the number of recessions required to complete a secular bear market. Previous secular bears since 1901 averaged between four and six. So far, since 2000 we have experienced only two and this means that there is probably a lot further to go. In the past the average time taken to completely unwind the optimism seen at a secular peak has been 18.6 years. The current US bear market is in its ninth year, again suggesting more trouble ahead. Chart 2 summarises these key benchmarks. The ellipses show the average peak, where the indicators were at the 2000 top, the average at the bear market lows and where we are today. The message is clear: we are currently some way from any form of signal.
The US Vs Japan
One interesting observation is that the Nikkei in Japan peaked in 1990 and has been in a downtrend ever since. In this respect, the Japanese market is ten years ahead of the US. Chart 3 therefore overlays the inflation adjusted S&P Composite over that of the Nikkei. The Japanese market (in blue) starts in 1975 and takes us up to the end of November. The green line is the S&P and it starts in 1985 and also ends in November. Please note that both series have once again been deflated by their respective consumer price indices (CPIs).
The 82 per cent drop in Japanese inflation-adjusted prices in a 20-year period compares with an average 66 per cent decline over 18.6 years in the US. That suggests that the Japanese market may be ready to experience a secular bull. I find it remarkable that the two markets with this ten-year lag have been acting fairly consistently with each other. This can best be appreciated with reference to the waves in the lower window of the chart. Currently the US market is in a primary trend bull, but if it follows the Japanese leadership we should expect to see a peak sometime next year, say July - that’s not a prediction by the way. A repeat of the Japanese experience would then call for a major decline into 2013.
Opening Year Of The Decade
This certainly does not sound very appealing and it’s not, but remember that the first year of the new decade is often a weak one. The opening years of the last twelve decades in the US have seen equity prices rise only four times. Three of the four - 1900, 1970 and 1980 - experienced sharp setbacks in the first half of the year. That just leaves 1950 as the only unscathed year. Clearly a time for caution.
Conclusion
Our forecast for the US over the next few years calls for an extended trading range with a downward bias. Nevertheless, we cannot rule out the possibility that in terms of absolute prices the secular low may already have been seen in a similar way to the 1932-49 and 1974-82 experiences. Whether it’s a trading range or a real bear market, the important point is that the investment challenges in the years ahead are likely to be formidable. Dow 35,000 was a popular title at the 2000 peak. May we suggest Dow 2,500 as an equally flawed title for the low whenever it comes? If you would like to see the full report on the secular bear market, please go to www.pringturner.com.
[PAGE BREAK]
Market Will Test 21,200
An analysis of the scrip movements of the companies mentioned below shows that they are poised to yield positive returns, especially in the long-term mode. Meanwhile, the possibility of the Sensex rising upwards to touch the 21,000 level cannot be ruled out too
BSE SENSEX
The Sensex has been in the midst of a recovery ever since it bottomed out by posting an intra-week low of 8,047.47 during the week ended March 6, 2009. The Sensex staged a recovery but declined to post an intra-week low of 8,110.10 during the week ended March 13, 2009, did not breach the earlier bottom and these levels have not been seen since. The Sensex commenced a superb intermediate uptrend (which later converted into a long-term up trend), posted a series of a progressively higher tops and bottoms, started moving into the confines of an upward sloping channel (refer to chart), peaked at an intra-week high of 15,600.30 during the week ended June 12, 2009 only to enter a corrective phase.
A rather severe correction was followed by a fabulous recovery, which also saw the resumption of its long-term uptrend. The Sensex rallied to post a fresh high of 16,002.46 during the week ended August 7, 2009 but this time around, had a rather sharp decline and it did not test its earlier intermediate bottom but posted a higher bottom of 14,684.45 during the week ended August 21, 2009. Currently, the Sensex has continued its sequence of newer highs and has not only posted a fresh high but is also within reasonable proximity of the 17,000 level. The Sensex needs to overcome the 17,337 level from a weekly point of view which means an upward movement to the 19,000 level or more while a test of the all time high of 21,200 cannot be ruled out.
GLENMARK PHARMA
Glenmark Pharma bottomed out by posting an intra-week low of 119.15 during the week ended February 6, 2009, gave an upward bar reversal, overcame the 5 Week EMA, launched into an intermediate uptrend, posted a series of progressively higher tops and bottoms, started moving within the confines of an upward sloping channel and ultimately rallied to peak at an all time high of 268.00 during the week ended May 29, 2009. Glenmark Pharma entered a corrective phase which turned out to be of rather severe proportions and declined to post an intra-week low of 199.05 during the week ended June 19, 2009 but strong support from the 13 week EMA provided the necessary cushion for an instant recovery.
Glenmark Pharma commenced a rather hesitant uptrend from here (which hasn’t yet converted into a long-term uptrend), started moving in the confines of a broad trading range (refer to chart) and continues to do so even now while for the first time over a long period there have been some sparks of life as it has given an upward breakout from a symmetrical triangle on the weekly chart. This promises to convert the move into a long-term uptrend.
[PAGE BREAK]
ICSA INDIA
ICSA India bottomed out by posting an intra-week low of 048.35 during the week ended March 13, 2009 when a deep oversold situation prevented a further fall while positive divergence across indicators was sporadic rather than uniform. ICSA India overcame its intermediate top and set off on an overdue rally, which saw it overcome the 13 Week EMA and ultimately peaked at an intra-week high of 126.60 during the week ended April 17, 2009. It bottomed out by posting an intra-week low of 104.05 during the week ended April 29, 2009 and moved sideways for the next few weeks before giving an upward breakout by closing above its downward sloping channel during the week ended May 8, 2009.
This upward breakout triggered off the resumption of a medium-term uptrend which had taken the form of an upward sloping channel. ICSA India has since then moved sideways in a protracted consolidation phase indicating the possibility of a long-term base being built, which could set off the scrip on an overdue long-term uptrend while the downside now appears limited.
PRAJ INDUSTRIES
Praj Industries bottomed out by posting an intra-week low of 049.10 during the week ended October 31, 2008, gave an upward key reversal, staged a smart but unsustainable rally and retraced this rise by posting an intra-week low of 045.10 during the week ended March 6, 2009. It almost gave an upward key reversal from here, took some support, sustained above the 5 Week EMA, entered an intermediate uptrend, posted a series of progressively higher tops and bottoms, started moving within the confines of an upward sloping channel and ultimately peaked with an all time high of 122.55 during the week ended June 5, 2009 only to decline again.
Praj Industries entered a corrective phase which turned out to be rather sharp, especially when keeping in mind the quantum of its rise and carried on to post an intra-week low of 070.00 during the week ended July 17, 2009. The index posted a higher bottom of 077.90 during the week ended November 6, 2009 and another higher bottom of 079.90 during the week ended November 27, 2009. Meanwhile, the bigger picture continues to remain positive and with the long-term uptrend set to commence, the scrip seems set to appreciate further from here.
[PAGE BREAK]
Peak Of 2008 By Jan 2010
Taking into consideration the long-term wave tree of the Sensex, it is quite possible that there will be celebrations at the beginning of 2010 and investors and traders would do well to benefi t from the movement towards the higher range
Chart I given herewith is the yearly one since the availability of the official BSE Sensex data of 1979. Each bar represents one calendar year. The markings done on the chart show that the entire rally from 1979 to 2008 can be coined as Wave I of the Super Cycle. The rise has been for the past 30 years and therefore cannot end in just one and a half years. In term of price, the entire rise has tested the 61.8 per cent retracement level which was at 8,070 wherein we witnessed lows of 7,696 and 8,047. It may be possible that price-wise the correction could be over but time-wise the correction is yet to come.
Even if it moves and tests a peak of 21,206, we could still be in the corrective cycle of the rise. The bullish and bearish markets are a sub-set of impulsive and corrective structures. The move from 21,206 is expected to be in a flat pattern and we have completed Wave W and Wave X termination which is likely in the near term. A confirmation of the same is awaited. If Wave X is completed, Wave Y has the potential to retrace the entire rise of Wave X unless, of course, Wave Y is proved to be a failure.
Chart II shows the monthly chart projection for Wave X. This is currently going on and can get terminated at either of the projections marked on the chart. The levels are 17,878-19,518-21,158. These would be the levels for a normal flat pattern. If the Sensex moves higher, it can go for an irregular flat structure. In that case, the extended levels for Wave X can be 24,439-26,171. If the Sensex fails to sustain at its current levels or at the 17,878-19,518-21,158 levels then the slide can begin to ideally test back the low of 8,047. If we assume that Wave X is complete at 17,750 then we can project Wave Y. If Wave Y is to be a failure, we may see a downward slide to 12,485-10,934-9,383 as shown in Chart III.
Yearly Pivot
Taking into consideration the readings for 2010, the Yearly Level 3 is placed at 20,439 (on the basis of the closing of December 10, 2009). This level will change depending on the price movement till December 31, 09. The Yearly Level 4 is placed at 29,885. The Yearly Centre Point is at 14,243 and Yearly Level 2 is placed at 10,993. The Yearly Centre Point may certainly be visited in 2010 and to an outer extent of 10,093. If Wave X completes shortly then Wave Y can move down to test the Yearly Centre Point and Yearly Level 2.
[PAGE BREAK]
Alternative
If the breakout and close above 21,206 is very strong and vertical then Wave 5, which we have terminated at 21,206, would have unfolded in its further internals. In that case it is possible that the rise from 2,904 to 21,206 would be treated as Wave (i) of Wave 5. Wave (ii) gets completed at 8,047 and Wave (iii) of Wave 5 would then be in progress. A shift to its alternative would depend on the angle of ascent and the impulsive nature of movement. At this point, the rise from 8,047 does not look to be an impulsive move and therefore we stand by the wave structure of Wave X as a part of the flat pattern.
Conclusion
On the basis of the above argument and hypothesis, we can draw a conclusion that year 2010 could see a range of 17,878-19,518-21,158 and maybe a range of 24,439-26,171 to an outer extent. The probability is that Wave X is either over or about to get over or may get over in the range of 17,878-19,518-21,158. By the time this is read, we could have seen lot of price development in a period of about a month or so. It is quite possible that we will celebrate in the first fortnight of January 2010, the second anniversary of the peak of 2008. The normal range of January 2010 will be 20,439 to 21,423. Investors and traders need to move with important higher bottoms in order to take the benefit of moves towards the higher range. The important higher bottoms at this point are 16,210 and 15,530.
[PAGE BREAK]
Get Market Returns With ETFs
Index ETFs provide excellent returns, convenience and easy liquidity for the small investors
The Indian market is attractive to investors in the developed markets, since the growth rates expected of Indian economy is much higher (in the range of 7-9 per cent) than expected in the developed markets (0-2 per cent). The portfolio allocations from international investors are likely to continue and in the medium term (3 to 7 years) our market is expected to generate good returns for the investors. Investors would do well to have exposure in the range of 20-60 per cent of their medium term portfolio to high quality equity schemes.
Regular equity investors may also opt for new innovative value averaging investment plan (VIP) or systematic transfer plan (STP) on Benchmark S&P CNX 500 Fund which is based on a formula and allows you to invest more in the falling market and less when markets are moving up, back testing results show a higher returns to the extent of 3.5 per cent for VIP as compared to Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) as this method takes the emotion out of the investment decision and helps the investor to invest in disciplined manner.
Indexing or Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) have gained popularity in global markets. With a large number of institutional investors in the market, it has become impossible for any active investor to consistently beat the market, hence the best way to participate in the market is through index funds.
ETFs are the most efficient route to take exposure to an index and when compared to any other open ended index funds ETFs are transparent, low cost, traded on the exchange just like any other stock and offers solution across asset classes.
How one can you use ETFs?
You can diversify your core equity holding with a single ETF unit
• Use it to build a long term core holding of equity by systematically investing in various index funds like Nifty ETF, Nifty Junior ETFs, Bank ETF etc
• If bullish on market, just buy a index ETF and no need to do individual stock picking
• If you have some stock in your portfolio, just do a switch trade by selling the stocks in your portfolio and buying an Index ETF of your choice
• Taxation is like shares (long term capital gain is zero and short term is 15 per cent)
[PAGE BREAK]
Mutual Funds Strategy
Stage Set For A Paradigm Shift
With a strong and proactive regulatory mechanism in place, the Indian MF industry may be expected to score even higher against the parameters of sustained asset growth, transparency and regulatory compliance
In my last article for DSJ (Dec. 22, 2008 edition) I had written about the need for the Indian mutual fund (MF) industry to get back to basics: serving the retail investor through better product innovation and distribution. After all, that is what MFs are meant to do. The industry, post-October 2008, is clearly moving towards acquiring better distribution capabilities through extensive use of technology, thereby overcoming some of the constraints posed by infrastructural bottlenecks.
It can be justifiably said that the aftermath of the October 2008 liquidity crisis marks a distinctive phase in the evolution of the Indian MF industry. The crisis brought out the best in both the regulator and the MF industry, thereby reinforcing the industry’s fundamentals. Besides, it also signalled a paradigm shift from the way the MF business was done in the past.
As the calendar draws to a close, we are in the process of leaving behind us memories of the dark days that saw the financial markets on the verge of collapse. India has shown great resilience, and now appears to be on the path of rapid economic recovery, encouraged by heavy domestic demand—one of the main pillars of our GDP growth. The future looks promising and should prove to be so, provided we bear in mind the three lessons the past has taught us: diversify risks, improve transparency, and ensure better compliance.
In the following sections we look at the impact that the regulatory measures taken since October 2008 are having on the Indian MF Industry and at some of the broad numbers; we also make an attempt at evaluating some of the recent trends in the industry.
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) announced a series of regulations to protect the interests of investors and reinforce the Industry fundamentals
Regulation and Impact
In December 2008, SEBI stipulated that all closed-ended debt schemes be compulsorily listed on the stock exchanges and banned premature withdrawals in close-ended debt schemes. It stipulated tenure limits for investments in securities by close ended schemes of similar tenure. Following the October 2008 crisis, these measures addressed the anomaly in the MF debt segment, where the fund manager faced an illiquid market but offered the investor ready liquidity. Thus in one stroke, the investor’s concern over liquidity was addressed while the fund manager was relieved of the bother of having to offer liquidity windows
[PAGE BREAK]
In January 2009, SEBI put a cap of three months on maturity of the papers that liquid funds can hold. SEBI mandates that use of the name “Liquid Plus Scheme” be discontinued since it conveys a wrong impression of added liquidity. This move puts in place a strong regulatory guideline for investments in keeping with the spirit of liquid funds and ensures that these funds function as intended, that is, as a vehicle for parking short-term funds. MFs were banned from declaring indicative returns and yields under fixed maturity plans (FMPs). The move prevented the possibility of investors misinterpreting indicative yield as guaranteed return.
In March 2009, monthly portfolio disclosure norms were introduced for debt oriented close-ended and interval schemes/plans. This move provided for greater transparency and disclosures to investors.
In June 2009, MFs were told to cap investment in money market instruments of a single entity at 30 per cent by September 5, 2009. This move puts in place a prudent investment risk management and diverse exposure guideline.
From August 1, 2009, SEBI abolished entry load for MF schemes. This piece of regulation has been the game changer in the MF and financial products distribution industry. While it has set off major structural changes in the industry and the distribution community, it should also serve well to promote investor awareness, financial literacy and knowledge based investment. With entry load abolished, the market is expected to shift from commission-based selling to service-oriented sales. This is likely to lead to conviction-based investment and improve asset stickiness for the industry. While the Independent Financial Advisor community had been hit hard initially by this piece of regulation, the impact is expected to wear off soon and pave the path for the emergence of better informed advisors with stronger service abilities and therefore better earning capability.
The focus is expected to shift from mere product sales to financial planning and advisory. The MFs were also asked to charge exit load within the stipulated limit of 7 per cent and without discrimination to any specific group of unit holders. This has removed possibilities of discrimination between small ticket retail investors, high net worth individuals (HNIs), and institutional investors, placing them all on equal footing.
Impact of reforms on MF industry post-financial crisis
Improvement in liquidity conditions in the Indian market along with revival in investor confidence has helped the domestic MF industry tide over the problems spawned by the October 2008 liquidity crisis. The strong recovery of the industry is reflected by the growth in assets under management (AUM) of debt schemes. The average AUM increased more than two-fold post-October 2008 to reach Rs 5,88,053 crore as on November 30, 2009.
There were apprehensions regarding debt funds after the SEBI norms on close-ended debt schemes were implemented in December 2008. Marketers predicted that FMPs would soon become unattractive and they would report a decline in assets. It was also said that the cap on liquid funds would reduce returns considerably.
[PAGE BREAK]
In fact, as expected, FMP assets reported a substantial reduction to Rs 22,410 crore in November 2009 from the peak of Rs 102,764 crore touched in September 2008. Also, as predicted, the average returns under liquid funds (open-ended growth schemes) fell from nearly 7.65 per cent simple annualised on December 31, 2008 to 3.27 per cent as on November 30, 2009.
The ultra short-term funds have reported a significant increase in AUM over the one year period. AUM under ultra short-term funds jumped to Rs 385,639 crore in November 2009 from Rs 109,398 crore in August 2008. While improvement in liquidity contributed to the rise in demand for debt schemes, capping the maturity of investments in liquid schemes led to increased preference for ultra short term funds.
The experience of calendar year 2009 has taught asset management companies (AMCs) a tough lesson in diversification. Today, the maximum allocation by a debt scheme to a real estate company stands at a mere 15 per cent or so, as against 60 per cent as on September 2008. These high exposure levels were concentrated more in the liquid and ultra short-term or Liquid Plus Funds and FMPs. The exposure to securitised debt instruments has also declined quite significantly.
Some other significant developments in the industry
SEBI and AMFI have mandated that bond valuation would be done by two agencies instead of only CRISIL at present. ICRA has been mandated by AMFI as the second agency and has already launched its valuation matrices. The regulatory move is aimed at instilling additional confidence in investors about the valuation of non-traded corporate bonds. With the two premier agencies valuing non-traded bonds independently, a better price discovery mechanism is likely to emerge.
In December 2009, Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and National Stock Exchange (NSE) launched an online mutual fund trading platform through existing equity brokers, thereby providing a secondary market to investors. This is expected to enhance MF penetration by increasing the points of presence. Simply put, the move unleashes a large regulated distribution force with a deep retail reach in Tier-II and Tier-III towns, thereby offering a great opportunity to the industry to increase penetration levels. The initial results have been very encouraging. In the course of time it may emerge that IFAs would tie up with broking entities that are regulated in a hub-and-spoke arrangement as in the equity segment. This would also enable investors to obtain advice on offerings and financial planning opportunities under a single roof.
MFs may soon have to disclose every month-end, the break-up of their AUM (equities and debt), the pattern of client holdings (institutional and retail) in their schemes, and their investments in group companies. This investor-friendly move would help investors make better informed decisions and serve the interests of all types of investors.
SEBI has proposed that fund management charges be brought down as MF schemes garner more AUMs.
[PAGE BREAK]
SEBI has asked fund houses to actively participate in management forums such as Annual General Meetings of the companies in which they are invested.
SEBI has proposed that the minimum number of investors that an MF scheme can have be raised from 20 to 50.
SEBI has proposed that the maximum holding of an investor currently be pared from 25 per cent to 10-15 per cent.
Today, the Indian MF industry can lay claim to having a world-class regulatory framework, one with the ability and willingness to evolve, which in itself is a pointer to its sensitivity to the requirements of the financial markets. With a strong and proactive regulatory mechanism in place, the Indian MF industry may be expected to score even higher against the parameters of sustained asset growth, transparency and regulatory compliance.
Debt Strategy
Wait And Watch
Investors should wait for the next two months before deploying funds in fi xed term plans, as short-term rates are likely to move up substantially
Now that last year’s volatility has subsided, there is evidence that Indian business activity has made a turnaround from Q4 FY09 and has seen its output rebound sharply. Though the broad trend of an unfolding recovery seems clear, many of us are surprised by the strength and the speed of it. A large and timely dose of monetary and fiscal stimulus drove this speedy recovery in India, which wasn’t as affected by last year’s credit crisis given its healthier banks and less leveraged consumers. Public sector spending has exploded in our country in the last 18 months, creating enormous demand that has prevented our economy from falling into a supply glut or debt trap.
Policy makers always respond to recessions with low rates and higher public expenditure, but the unique feature of 2008-09’s recession has been that the response has been global, aggressive and sustained. Now, given that we are likely to grow at about 6.5-7.5 per cent for the next three years, with 4.5-5.5 per cent inflation, our policy rates should be in the 5.5-6.5 per cent range. Here, our assumption is that long-term growth and inflation rates in India are 7 per cent and 5 per cent respectively. Against this backdrop, as we expect growth to sustain at long-term average rates we believe money will get costlier in the coming years.
As it is likely that interest rates will inch up across the year, with short-term rates aligning to elevated policy rates, it makes sense to postpone buying of medium-term debt instruments for the next few months. We see short-term FD rates and money market rates inching up in the run up to March. But we should be mindful of the fact that our system is still awash with excess liquidity and the demand for private credit is low, as a result of which long-term rates may not move up substantially.
[PAGE BREAK]
When the policy rates fly high over the next few quarters, there is a case to invest in floating bond funds as they protect investors from depreciation in value when rates rise. Medium-term funds are aptly positioned to benefit from the coming tighter policy regime. Investors should wait for the next two months before deploying funds in fixed term plans, as short-term rates are likely to move up substantially.
The bull market of credit spreads has entered its last leg. The rapid spread squeeze in both high and low grade bonds have removed most of the under-valuation created by the panic crash in October. Still, the spreads are unlikely to move up substantially until there are visible signs of credit pick-up or liquidity withdrawal. Going forward, there are two key risks associated with fixed income funds viz. credit and duration risk. Duration is the key risk associated with short-term and income funds given the prospects of curve flattening and rise in short-term rates. Ultra short-term rates are trading at historically low levels and should swiftly move up in sight of liquidity tightening and rate moves.
Fortunately, most of the funds are already prepared for this and therefore investors may not lose much in these funds. The credit risk quotient has come off significantly across mutual funds and is unlikely to pose significant risk to the investors. But at the same time, investors should be wary of buying low credit papers or funds as the spreads have shrunk significantly and offer little compensation for the associated credit and liquidity risks of the underlying companies’ bonds.
Equity Strategy
AsiaMarching Ahead
Even as other countries are still struggling to come out of the depths of the economic meltdown, Asian countries like India and China have already made swift recoveries and are on their way to posting impressive GDP fi gures. This certainly bodes well for the future
W e expect 2010 to be a year of re-balancing for both, the global economy and financial markets. Asia has excellent banking systems, undervalued currencies and large current account surpluses while the developed economy is the complete opposite. The G7 will need further time to heal themselves while the impact of their own fiscal stimuli fades. In turn, Asia will be expected to grow above the trend either through higher consumption or by moving further up the value-added curve by offering higher services. Equally, Asia will need to lift their exchange rates to increase the purchasing power of residents to acquire overseas assets, thereby recycling the large domestic surpluses into deficit economies.
[PAGE BREAK]
With Asia and the emerging markets leading the global economy out of the 2008 slump, these economies will still need to maintain a relatively relaxed monetary policy to ensure that growth is self-sustaining. Since Asia is still very much driven by exports the local central banks may find themselves running a monetary policy far looser and far longer than would normally be warranted. With little room in some cases to expand fiscal deficits, we would expect the central banks to buy some growth insurance by keeping interest rates low.
With producer prices in many industries rising at their fastest rate in annualised terms during the past 25 years in Asia, the risk of an ‘inflation echo’ is growing. Global PMI manufacturing data continues to expand, while the recent China PMI and US ISM manufacturing data argue for an ongoing economic rebound. Asian earnings are passing through a sweet spot — one where margins are expanding, operational gearing is rising and order backlogs are increasing.
The ‘short run’ needed to raise production in Asia has significantly lifted the prices — from shipping rates to drams to milk — creating a supernormal period for profits.
With the utilisation rates ramping up, inventory-to-shipment ratios low, companies running down low-cost raw materials, and with short-term pricing power, we think sales and margins are expanding commensurately. With earnings’ expectations low, the uplift in earnings’ revisions is the steepest on record. This has been having two unintended consequences. First, it has caused equities to sharply outperform bonds initially and second, it is ‘passing’ through cost-push inflation into the global economy.
Since the beginning of the year, food prices have rallied more than 10 per cent with the ‘breakfast commodities’ of tea, cocoa and sugar at their highest levels in 30 years. While speculative inflows were blamed on the price rises seen during 2007-08, the structural imbalances behind food production were just as much the cause. These imbalances have not disappeared as biofuels compete for land alongside grains, and increasing incomes in emerging-market economies demand much more protein. With the oil price flirting with USD 80 per barrel, there remain strong incentives for farmers to switch crops to those subsidised as biofuels.
The influence of climatic change and also the critically low levels of food stocks relative to consumption have caused prices to rise once again. With the global recession over, we believe there is likely to be increasing pressure on food prices to rise. As corn and rice prices are just starting to rise, it should have a significant impact on inflation. Since corn is used as feed for cattle and poultry, it directly impacts the price of meat. Rice is a major component of Asian CPI. We continue to like the soft commodity sector.
Trapped in maintaining a steep yield curve to resuscitate the banking system and using observations of capacity utilisation as a signal to lift rates, the Fed has invited risk takers to short the US dollar in pursuit of returns elsewhere. The depreciation of the US dollar alongside financial gearing is beginning to manifest itself in an ‘inflation echo’ through Asia as well as ever greater movement in asset prices. The two things investors would not have expected a year ago is an inflation jolt alongside frothy asset prices.
[PAGE BREAK]
For investors, there must be a balance in taking risks as well as marginalising correlations to external variables such as a weak US dollar. To date, a bar bell strategy seems appropriate. Regional telecoms are laggards with strong cash flows and have underperformed. Internet stocks exhibit high cash flow, are fast-growing and a proxy to consumption. Finally, Taiwan technology appears fairly priced, with strong net cash balance sheet support with operational gearing on the upside to surprises in demand.
Gold Strategy
Golden Days Ahead
Taking a cue from the behavioural pattern of gold in the past, it can be concluded that the recent peak is nothing but a burst of energy that takes place in the gold market every 17 weeks or so
Gold is certainly one of the most difficult markets to forecast and 2010 should make the challenge no less difficult. There are several observations, however, from a close study of the past that will help us understand the twists and turns of this market, as well as when to look for the most significant up and down moves to take place. To begin with, I call your attention to the vertical lines overlaid on the price of gold on the above weekly chart. These lines represent a 17-week reversal phenomenon that seems to be taking place in this market.
This is not a cycle. What it appears to be is a burst of energy, so to speak, in the gold market that takes place about every 17 weeks. It has been doing this for the last ten years or so. We should carefully look for market explosions to start at this time. This is when it is most apt to reverse the current direction. This can also be combined with the cyclical observations and seasonal indications. Speaking of cyclical observations, the second panel underneath the weekly price chart is what I refer to as my Natural Cycle. This is an interesting way of predicting future price.
It is based on the price action of years in the past that have a common analogy with the unknown year. In other words, certain things took place - say seven years ago, that should have an affect on gold in 2010. The years all have one thing in common and that is why I call this a Natural Cycle. I then take the average prices of these years to make the forecast year road map or pattern. As you can see, this approach calls for a top early in the year. Then it calls for a decline into April 2, with a long drawn-out rally topping around July 2. An ensuing decline bottoms the week of July 23 and August 27. That down move should kick off a rally in the middle of October, when again a decline comes into this market.
[PAGE BREAK]
While not perfect, this is an ‘unoptimised’ approach to forecasting the future. As you can see from the 2008 and 2009 predictions, my Natural Cycle has done a very good job of highlighting times when we should expect major moves in the gold market. The red line in the above chart is the forecast from the past. It is all based on data that was not known during the forecast year. No out of sample data is used. Next, let’s take a look at the blue line or the Decennial Pattern that is operating in the gold market. This is my application of the work by Edgar Lawrence Smith, except with a few twists and an application to gold. This is a long-term view of prices and certainly alerted investors to the massive rally in gold that began in the middle of 2009.
The Decennial Pattern is forecasting a down move for the first of 2010, then a low in mid-May and a peak around October 1. No forecast for gold would be complete without looking at the seasonal tendency of gold, which is shown in the bottom panel in black. That is a non-adaptive average of all price data from the prior years. While seasonals are good, I do not believe they are as precisely accurate as the other approaches that I use. Overlaid on top of the seasonal pattern I have placed the most dominant weekly cycles that are at work in gold this time.
The most dominant cycles, as I see it, are the 11, 17 and 21 week cycles. These have all been averaged together (in the purple line) which suggests when cyclical peaks and troughs are most apt to occur in 2010. As an aside, I should point out that if the market is rapidly advancing as it comes into a potential cyclical low in this indicator, we would expect a reversal of the advance, and vice versa. Cycle projections are more about reversals. Well, there you have it - what my studies from the past project gold in 2010. For more insightful forecasts of all futures markets and stock indices, visit my web site www.ireallytrade.com.
Real Estate Strategy
In A Stabilisation Mode
Economic slowdown took its toll on the real estate market in 2009, but improved macro-economic conditions will see the sector stabilizing in 2010
Indian real estate market started the year 2009 in the “declining” phase of the property cycle. 1Q09 witnessed the highest decline in rental and capital values for most of the commercial real estate micro-markets in the current downturn. Dwindled demand for commercial space significantly aggravated the oversupply situation. As a result, many of the under-construction projects were delayed and most of the projects completed during 2H08-1H09 commenced their operations with significantly higher vacancy levels.
Overall average rental value for office space in India has declined by 29.61 per cent during 1Q09-3Q09. However, average rental value decline slowed down from 18.8 per cent in 1Q09 to 5.7 per cent in 3Q09, reflecting the possibility of stabilization in the coming quarters. This was accompanied by gradual improvement in absorption rate from 7 per cent in 1Q09 to 15 per cent in 3Q09. Despite this, average vacancy level for office space has increased to 15 per cent in 3Q09, registering a y-o-y increase of 720 basis points. Initial yield for office real estate investments steadily increased during 2H08-1Q09, as capital values continued to decline faster than the decline in rental values. Due to the risk of oversupply and declining rental values, investors were seeking higher risk premium and scouting for deals with capitalization rate in the range of 13-15 per cent. Initial yield witnessed a trend reversal during 2Q09 when decline in rental values was higher than the decline in capital values on account of the floor effect on the capital values.
[PAGE BREAK]
Retail real estate market was more severely affected than the office real estate market in the current economic slowdown. The average rental value for retail stock declined by 33.14 per cent during 1Q09-3Q09. However, decline in average rental value has steadily slowed down from 17.5 per cent in 1Q09 to 7.8 per cent in 3Q09. On the other hand, average vacancy level in retail sector is expected to leap to approximately 20 per cent by end-09. This is because approximately 11.7 million sq ft of retail space is expected to be added during 2009, most of which are expected to commence their operation with no-so-good occupancy. Moreover, due to reduced pre-leasing in 2009, many mall developers are re-evaluating their mall development plans and some of them have deferred their mall completion plans
Similarly, residential real estate market also felt the shivers of the current economic slowdown. Net absorption dipped significantly and fewer new projects were launched during 2H08-1Q09 compared to previous quarters. Developers were desperate to enhance their cash-flow and hence slashed the brochure price of their residential projects in an attempt to improve the absorption. Also, they came up with customer-centric strategies and realigned their focus on affordable housing. As a result, demand started to come back and net absorption showed improvements since 2Q09. While absorption rate steadily declined from 24 per cent in 1Q08 to 9 per cent in 1Q09, it witnessed a turnaround in 2Q09 and has steadily improved to 21 per cent in 3Q09. After witnessing a decline of 20-35 per cent across precincts during 2H08-1H09, capital values have also shown signs of stabilization during 3Q09.
The 2010 Scenario
Indian real estate sector is expected to be in the stabilization mode at the commencement of 2010. Improved macro-economic conditions and substantial improvement in sentiments are likely to trickle down to the real estate sector. As such, real estate in India is expected to continue to build upon the improvements it has seen in the last two quarters. While office and residential sectors are likely to see substantial improvements, retail real estate market may continue to be sluggish for a while.
Office real estate market is soon expected to enter in the “recovery” phase of the property cycle. Absorption is expected to see 15-20 per cent increase from its 2009 levels. However, vacancy may continue to increase due to huge supply pipeline. As such, we do not expect any significant decline in rental values during 2010. Capital values have already started to show signs of stabilization. The current trend of yield compression is likely to continue in 2010.
On the contrary, retail sector is yet to see the bottom and may witness further decline in rental values during 2010. Due to robust supply pipeline and sluggish demand, vacancy in retail sector may continue to increase.
[PAGE BREAK]
However, residential real estate is likely to lead the pack and enter in the recovery mode first. We have already noticed instances where developers have increased their brochure price taking cues from the improved demand sentiments. We do not expect any noteworthy downside risk for capital values in the residential real estate market. To sum up, all sectors are likely to see more activities in 2010 than in 2009.
Investment and Policy Outlook
Office and residential sectors are nearing bottom in terms of decline in capital values. As finding the bottom can best be done with the benefit of hindsight, it makes a strong case to take an exposure in these two asset classes in the near-term. Along with that, investors should have a more than speculative term investment horizon as the returns may not that impressive in the short-term due to the possibility of muted recovery. With 3-5 years of investment horizon, real estate investments may provide returns better risk-adjusted returns than alternative investment avenues.
Transparency and paucity of channels of financing real estate development are hampering the growth aspiration of the sector. A nodal real estate regulator is required to check the excesses in the sector. Along with that, clarification on the issues related to taxation and valuation for REMF can enhance sources of funds for real estate development. Also, REIT guidelines are also expected to be formulated during 2010 which in the long term may have the potential to change the landscape of Indian real estate sector taking it to a higher orbit of growth. For the residential sector, government may need to provide higher FAR and additional tax benefits to the home buyers which in effect would reduce the residential cost of development
Diamond
Investment In Diamonds - The 'In Thing'
Gold and diamonds are increasingly being used as a hedge by HNWI of India, China and Russia. Hence, the emerging market in BRIC countries will push the demand for diamonds further north
During the peak of the recession in January of 2009, Jelena Jankovic, currently eighth ranked women tennis player of the world, was giving a regular interview at a popular sports channel. When asked as to what will be her choice if she was given an option to choose between a branded watch and a diamond ring, her reply was amazingly curt and candid, "Of course the diamond ring...you know a diamond is woman's best friend." It's amazing and at the same time reassuring to note that the friendship had not subsided at the height of the catastrophe which saw the consumer buying go into a tizzy with the collapse of Lehman brothers. Since then so many things in this world has changed permanently but an investor's bondage with the women's best friend has increased in direct proportion to the loss of confidence in paper stocks. The Raj Kundras and Saif Ali Khans went on publicly admonishing their love for their girlfriends with iconic diamond rings and gold and diamonds emerged as tools of investment with a vengeance. In fact when the world was seeing a meltdown of prices of other commodities like steel, copper, oil and etc, hard assets like gold, silver and diamond more or less held on to their prices which can instil strong faith in the minds of an investor during bad times.
[PAGE BREAK]
The value of gold and diamonds are derived intrinsically from their rarity. Though both gold and diamonds are extremely rare in nature, diamonds are rarer and have shown price appreciation steadily through the last 25 years. However gold has shown much greater promise and returns in comparison. Hence diamonds now look historically cheap in comparison to its asset class peers like gold or silver which has shown phenomenal increase and appreciation in prices through the last few years, especially this year with the decline in dollar, the primary fiat currency of the world. Both diamond and gold are US $ denominated assets as over 60 per cent of world's gold holdings are still in USA. Gold & diamonds are increasingly being used as a hedge by HNWI of India, China & Russia. The emerging market in BRIC countries will push the demand for diamonds further north.
Hence the latest 'in thing' in the world of investment is to invest in diamonds. Now De Beers has started a new campaign harping the prudence in investing in love and diamonds. This new found vigour of the world in diamonds is underlined by the launch of a number of diamond investment funds this year. This is driven by the growing demand for portfolio diversification by fund managers the world over with the failing of the paper scrips, the real estates and the commodity based futures during the crisis. Only gold and diamond had more or less remained unaffected during the savage onslaught on prices of different commodities. This has given the investors and fund managers food for though and a viable option.
In 2009 an electronic diamond exchange was launched by DODAQ (Dealers Organisation for Diamond Automated Quotes) to trade categories of polished diamonds. The DODAQ exchange is intended to be a terminal market for round polished certified diamonds (which is the most liquid part of the market) and hosts its centralised storage facility in a Freezone. The exchange is an attempt to overcome the traditional investment barriers of sales tax and low liquidity on the resale market. DODAQ offers two-way auctions for individual categories of polished diamonds, thus creating real time spot prices and the first cash market for diamonds. The trading platform is open to all, both within and outside of the industry, enabling diamonds to be realised for the first time as an asset class, and an alternative investment opportunity to gold.
The idea of investing in certified loose diamonds is attractive, especially in the current environment where mainstream investments appear risky. It is true that certified loose diamonds have tended to appreciate in value over time, and therefore can be resold at a future date often for considerable sums of money. In this way diamonds are much better "investments" than many other high priced items such automobiles which rapidly depreciate over time. However, those round brilliant diamonds with excellent cuts tend to retain their original value over odd cuts such as Emerald Cuts, or Radiant Cuts.
[PAGE BREAK]
The recent trends of diamond investment funds and promotion of diamonds by De Beers as safe haven investment suggests that more and more HNWIs of the Western world are also prone to taking the route of investment in diamonds. Another option for investors is the vintage diamond jewelry market -- considered capable of more lucrative returns because of the added value of provenance. Most of the auction houses are selling rare diamonds at phenomenal prices. A 5 carat cushion shaped fancy vivid pink diamond ring set not one but two world records at Christie’s Jewels sale in Hong Kong last week by selling at US $ 10.78 million, a whopping US$ 2.1 million per carat. If one considers the other use of diamond which magnifies its emotional quotient during trying times, then the ROI on diamond by an investor increases further.
Though there was a slight fall in diamond prices in the two quarters from January to June 2009, the increasing scarcity in supply of rough diamonds in the next decade will push up the prices of diamonds steadily. Without the discovery of any new big mine in gold & diamonds both of them getting rarer and according to some estimates within another 20-25 years the diamond reserves of the world may get exhausted.
In the short run also diamond will see increase in prices as there is scarcity in the market of quality diamonds as most of the mines have either reduced their production or gone on maintenance last year after the downturn and will take some time to reach their peak production capacities. It has been predicted that the demand of polished diamonds at manufacturers level which was US $ 13.7 billion in 2009 will increase by 25% to touch US $ 17.1 billion in 2010 though at consumer level the increase of sales of diamond jewellery of 2010.
If gold and diamond both derives its high value from their rarity and indestructible characteristics, then diamond falls way behind in standardisation as it has a complex algorithm for classification being dependent on the combination of cut, carat weight, colour, shape and clarity. These five characteristics together can throw thousands of permutations and combinations and price may vary accordingly which has made it so much difficult to classify diamond standards and the price it would command. However the basic quality of diamond prices are based on its rarity. An example is the bigger the diamond the rarer it is and hence the more the price. The same analogy can be drawn for colour, the transparent pieces being a norm the more the colour like pink, yellow and etc, the rarer it is.
The most advanced testing mechanisms are being used for certification by the most respected diamond grading labs in the world like Gemmological Institute of USA, popularly known as GIA, IGI (International Gemmological Institute) or HRD. The US and European consumers were always particular on the certifications through these laboratories or EGL (European Gemmological Laboratory), AGS or etc. Now most of these laboratories has set shop in India and the demand for certified diamonds amongst consumers is growing and being encouraged by the industry for achieving greater transparency and credibility.
[PAGE BREAK]
So what’s does the prescription look like- What is the best investment in diamonds today?
A single diamond usually termed as solitaire set in rings does not go up in value faster than say a pair or a matched set in a 3 stone ring.
But a single stone or solitaire may be more liquid than a collection. A single stone might cost less to set.
Medium quality diamonds (with no visible imperfections or obvious discoloration) are more saleable, and go up in value at a proportional rate to rarer more expensive diamonds like D Flawless or VVS quality.
Princess cuts are hot at the moment, but in a few years they will be passé. Heart shapes, marquise and other shapes come and go in fashion. Round brilliant cut diamonds are definitely the best most resell-able in the long-term.
90% of round diamonds are poorly cut. A clever buyer will buy a non-traditional ‘Ideal Cut’ diamond that will fit into the new GIA and AGS best cut standards.
Fancy colored pink diamonds may become rare if the Australian Argyle mine output falls as appears likely. But pinks are hard to re-sell.
Economy
India: Resilient, Strong, But….
There may not be too much of an upside to growth in the next fi scal as there would be some attempts at withdrawing stimulus packages in India and globally.
The memory of the October of 2008 is hard to erase from my mind: the Lehman crash and the mayhem that was unleashed into the financial markets at that point in time. The sharp rise in the asset prices, especially housing on the back of very easy monetary policy had created the sub-prime loan problems in the US. Most market participants were aware of the sub-prime problems in the US, but never had anyone, not even the policy makers, imagined its potential to balloon out into a Great Depression-like scenario. But when Lehman went bust, the credit markets globally came to a standstill and a confidence crisis manifested itself into a liquidity crisis.
In response to this, monetary policy globally has taken a very interesting unconventional turn. Official rates in some countries moved close to or at zero per cent and central banks under such instances also had to resort to outright asset purchases, commonly called “Quantitative Easing”. And this was generally the accepted norm through most of the first half of calendar 2009. These measures served to ease the sharp liquidity crunch; the financial market parameters improved and the level of activity in many economies appear to be stabilizing. And, with liquidity so easily available, the riskier assets – read equities – have rallied.
[PAGE BREAK]
The situation was no different in India. The much publicized “decoupling” argument for India failed to work and with the Lehman bust the FIIs started to sell in India and take out money to meet their own redemption pressures abroad. In a single month, RBI had to sell around USD 18 bn to support the selling pressure of the FIIs. And this sparked off a chain reaction and all entities within the financial system started to feel the pain. RBI reacted swiftly to this situation and reduced the CRR by 400 bps, reduced the reverse repo and the repo rates and also instituted unconventional measures of monetary easing such as reducing the statutory liquidity ratio (SLR) mandate of banks from 25 per cent to 24 per cent and also allowed for special liquidity lines for the NBFCs, HFCs and the MFs.
It was also realized early that the economic crisis would have a negative impact on the demand side of the economy. The Indian economy was growing at 9-9.5 per cent and a significant bit of the consumption in India was also out of supernormal gains in the equity markets. The employers got nervous as manpower emerged as excess, especially in the export segment and this nervousness also rubbed on the employees in the form of job loss fears. Here, India was a bit lucky in the sense that the two biggest stimulus packages that worked on the demand side, namely the 6th Pay Commission awards and the farm loan waiver were instituted long before the crisis erupted and the first tranche of arrears under the Pay Commission awards were also doled out in October 2008. This along with enhancement of NREGA programme and also some tax cuts formed the fiscal focus to fight the crisis till the first 3-4 months of 2009.
The situation appears more normal now and the global attention has moved away from managing the crisis to managing the recovery. The trough in the growth dynamics in the global scenario appears to have been achieved and most of the indicators, such as business and consumer confidence appear to signal the process of recovery. The pace of job losses in the US has progressively moderated and as of the last report, the unemployment rate has also moved lower to 10 per cent for November from 10.2 per cent in the previous month. The risk assets continued to do well in the second half of 2009 in the face of surplus liquidity conditions and a belief that the extreme low interest rates will continue for a significant period of time.
But all might not yet be well in the global economic scenario. And that is possibly the reason why economics and financial market gurus continue to debate the shape of the economic recovery – V, U, W, or L? To me, the recovery should more be like a U but with the lower curve of the U extending for a longer period, maybe even as long as one year or even more. Reason is simple: we are still to see much in the form of an evidence of any significant growth in the bank lending or broad monetary growth in the global economies. Credit growth remains weak because banks themselves continue to remain risk-averse and consumers have still not repaired their own balance sheets to be able to make fresh borrowings. Timothy Geithner, the US Treasury Secretary, also recently pointed out that the credit crunch in the US is still not over. US consumers are still reeling under the pressure of unemployment and loss of income even as they see the prices of their assets not recovering at a fast pace to be able to reduce their debt. And added to this, the current focus has moved to a much more dangerous issue of sovereign defaults.
[PAGE BREAK]
What can we say of India? Definitely it has proved its resilience once more, the first time during the East Asian currency crisis of 1997. The crumble in growth dynamics was not as deep as was expected, possibly due to the timely demand-boosting stimulus in the form of 6th Pay commission arrears and the Farm loan waivers. While IIP growth averaged at only 0.4% in H2 of 2008-09 compared to 5.3% in H1, India’s GDP growth dipped to only 5.8% in H2 of 2008-09 from 7.8% in H1. The reason is a very strong growth in the “community, social and personal” services in the H2. But the most important thing standing for India is that in this round of crisis, the banking sector has come out almost absolutely unscathed. And we should thank RBI under Dr Reddy for this achievement, when in the rest of the world the banking sector has taken a hit. For the RBI it was probably not an easy decision to impose counter-cyclical policy measures and try to arrest an asset price bubble, when its counterparts in most of the developed world failed.
The other important structural change worth noting for India is the resilience of rural demand, even in the face of a severe drought. True, even today 60 per cent of India’s population lives in the villages but much of the rise in income and consumption of the rural India did not have much to do with agriculture. Over the years, better rural roads, electricity connectivity and penetration of communication services have enabled ancillary services industry and export oriented industries to flourish in the rural areas, bringing in most of consumption power. And in the immediate analysis, the lower agriculture incomes were negated by schemes such as the NREGA programme in which the government has increased its outlay significantly to Rs 39,000 crore.
Thus, I would be confident in saying that the worst is over for India. However, the jury is still out on whether the consumption demand has revived enough for the government’s fiscal stimulus and RBI’s monetary stimulus to be removed. My sense is that some hand-holding may still be necessary for the moment. However, as 2008 was the year of the crisis, 2009 was the year of stimulus and stabilization; at some point in 2010 we are probably likely to see gradual withdrawal of stimulus not only in India but globally. True, the challenge for the withdrawal process would be to time it rightly and calibrate it properly.
And this is where there could be some problems for India. First, there is not much scope for the fiscal deficit to come down immediately, even as some space is vacated by the 6th Pay Commission’s arrear payments. The reason is that the burden of higher salaries would continue while the high borrowing programme will add significantly to the interest payment burden to the extent of almost Rs 25,000 crore each year, a wasteful expenditure. Thus fiscal consolidation is likely to be some way off. But, history suggests that any attempt by the US Fed to reverse its easy monetary policy is likely to lead to dips in the prices of risk assets, including equity. This could also reduce the foreign flows to the Indian markets and in the face of a high borrowing programme of the government, the risk is for the Indian economy to be led back to the old days of “crowding out”.
[PAGE BREAK]
And this could be unfortunate for India’s growth dynamics from a longer term perspective. Finding funds for the infrastructure growth could remain a problem and hence would be a hindrance for any sustained upward swing in the growth dynamics. And as high fiscal deficits feed into inflation expectations, interest rates are also likely to stay on the higher side, and are likely to also impede growth. I would not expect too much of an upside to growth in the next fiscal as there would be some attempts at the withdrawal of stimulus packages globally. And it is definitely likely to be some extended time period before we can hope to get back to the 8.5 per cent territory. Equity markets are likely to stay volatile in 2010 as liquidity is withdrawn from global financial markets. And I must say that the challenges in 2010 would be huge and as I say adieu to 2009, I hope I am proven to be significantly off the mark so far as my capability of crystal ball gazing is concerned. Wishing all my readers a Happy 2010 anyways!
Economy Strategy
Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde Of The Economy
Central banks have to manage rational expectations in a vigorous and sound manner to prevent them from becoming ‘animal spirits’, says Dr Shunmugam
Choosing to chase inflation rates using all monetary tools aimed at controlling inflationary expectations (price instability), the central banks and the policymakers worldwide are, at least after the financial crisis, coming to an agreement that they had jointly chased the ‘mirage of price stability’ using all tools at their disposal leaving the larger culprit of financial instability (asset price bubbles, OTC market risks, performance pay and salaries of corporates and banks) at their back.
Faced with a larger threat of financial instability rather than price instability, as was the lesson learnt from the recent financial crisis, there seems to be an unannounced agreement among them that ensuring financial stability would be their primary task, an offshoot of which would be otherwise held as the main task of ensuring price stability and control. The current tone of our central bank as per the recent BPLR and the later credit policy document is that it would not only set the benchmark lending rates but also let banks deliver them in an appropriately risk-weighted manner, which is a right policy in that direction. The expectation is that the rates would be adjusted sectorally as per the perceived risk of the sector’s contribution to the overall financial instability not from the macro allocation viewpoint but from the micro retail lending point of view. Let us see here what role Dr Jekyll (the interest rate) and Mr. Hyde (asset price expectations) play out in an economy from a real-life perspective.
[PAGE BREAK]
Ram is a Mumbai-based wholesale trader who buys grains and other agricultural products from nearby mandis and stores and distributes them among Mumbai retailers who are his customers. As it takes some time between his buy and sell decisions, and there are costs and risks involved in the process, he builds his costs and market risks into his price expectations and appropriately makes his exit (timing and price) expectations. A part of the cost that gets added to is the interest rate expectations i.e. the interest rate that he loses by investing it in his wholesale trading business compared with the next best possible opportunity that he loses. One such opportunity, according to him, would be one of his own side-businesses of lending his excess liquidity to the needy in an informal manner and getting the money back at a rate usually ranging from 24-36 per cent depending on his borrower’s history and net worth, besides various other criteria that he applies in his mind before offering him a loan.
The existence of a thriving unorganized market to lend to the risk-bearing and needy population not only makes capital expectations of wholesale traders such as Ram higher making the supply chains costlier in their operations but also makes the income earned from interest in such cases tax-free. While deciding his rate to this informal sector he also calculates the formal rates and builds higher expectations as the formal rates go up and as his cost of living rises leading to a further increase in the rate that he charges.
Ram, as a result, earns much higher profits than what his consumption needs are and he seeks avenues to invest in apart from the regular deposit that he makes in various banks he has accounts with, in an effort to accumulate them for investing larger assets for his children keeping in mind their future educational and life requirements. As he accumulates a certain amount of money, he at times buys a property such as a plot of land or a house in his native village or a flat in Mumbai, which he knows for sure will appreciate in its value so that he can earn that value both in the short term and in the long term. Those short-term profits that he has been making is purely for the purpose of profiteering from the property price movements apart from the share market movements and, in the long term, his investments have been to help his children pay up for the best of education he should buy for them. Besides, through long-term investments he also makes sure that the future needs of his children are taken care of by providing them with properties that they can live on.
Being in the early 50s and in the business for the last 25 years, and having prudently managed it, he had already completed most of his investments for long-term purposes including other sources of income such as farming an orchard, maintaining a small dairy unit, etc. His children went to study abroad and the money for the same had already been kept in cash to meet all their current and future needs until they become self-reliant. He has a lifestyle superior to that of his neighbours and relatives alike. Hence, he is looking for short-term profits at this point in life for scaling up his business. He is also currently planning to vertically integrate his business so that he can tap other profit-making opportunities in the value chain. To fulfill his ambitions, Ram started increasingly investing in the stock markets about 3 years ago. Apart from investments in the real estate sector and the stock market, Ram had also scaled up his warehousing capacities so that he can stock products (of course, within prescribed legal restrictions) in order to reap the value of storage.
[PAGE BREAK]
Then there came a bad instance of a wrong business decision during early 2008, which led to a loss during the latter part of the year. It required that he should unwind his existing investment positions in order to pay up for it and still pursue his ambitions. It also included the stocks that he had just bought about a few months ago, during May/June 2008, when the markets were nearing their peak. Looking at the way the markets were rolling down and the ability of the real estate markets to withstand the same, fearing further losses he decided to unwind his investments in the stock markets leading to an erosion of the value of his invested money. Being unable to meet up for the business losses, added with cash and bank savings, he, after having discussion with the brokers he had been in touch with, also decided to wind up his real estate investments in areas witnessing a demand slowdown. Good for him that India’s real estate markets, unlike the stock markets, did not react much to the 2008 financial crisis leaving Ram and other like him with the wisdom in the current year that real estate is a safe investment avenue besides his savings/fixed deposit account with banks. Given the growth in the sector that Ram and his peers are contributing to, it does not mean that they can create a bubble with the potential to erode financial stability that the central bankers have today vowed for as their objective.
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde of our story are not characters who have their own ways of playing out, but it is our expectations (like the typical case of Ram: how he and many like him were part of the market slide and how they can create the same with the real estate sector) which play them out in our big film about economic growth. It is exactly where the current credit policy is cracking whips, rightly identifying sectoral fund flow, rate management and risk identification as the major task in an effort to manage these expectations in a more vigorous and sound manner. If Shiller says, humans can be driven by ‘animal spirits’ of herding together, the central bank rightly identified in its recent credit policy that it has ways to prevent such herding among participants so that the markets can be driven by ‘rational expectations’ rather than ‘animal spirits’. Of course, what is ‘rational expectations’ in a given situation is arguable which would have to be discovered by independent participants in a decentralized manner with easy access to a platform where they can collectively express the same.
Assets Allocation
A State Of Equilibrium
To be able to achieve your investment goals while riding the highs and lows of the various phases that rock the markets, rely on an asset allocation strategy that spreads your money across different asset classes
Investment is about risk and expected return,” said Nobel Prize winner William F Sharpe. “No one likes risk and the higher an investment’s expected return, the better.” The truth, however, is that if you don’t take enough risk on your portfolio, your investments may not earn returns required to meet your long-term investment goals. On the other hand, if you take too much risk with your investments, you may have to compromise on some of the important financial goals. The real issue, therefore, is how can one find and maintain one’s balancing point that can ensure success in achieving investment goals at a risk level one is comfortable with.
[PAGE BREAK]
This is where an asset allocation strategy has a role to play. An asset allocation strategy aims at spreading your money across different asset classes such as equity, debt, real estate and commodities. That’s because if one asset class is losing money, the other asset class may be earning for you. In other words, asset allocation is a form of diversification and if properly done, reduces portfolio risk more than it compromises returns. Simply put, if your portfolio has a mix of two investments that tend to go in opposite directions in different market situations, the combination has a stabilising effect on your portfolio. Similarly, even if both the securities are ‘risky’, they can and do deviate substantially from their expected returns.
It is a proven fact that different asset classes perform differently in different market conditions. For example, stock market does well during an economic boom, and loses ground during recessionary times. The bond market, however, goes in the opposite direction.
While the recessionary conditions are good for the bond markets, a booming economy is not so good for it. Today, investors have plenty of investment options to choose from. However, the complexities in the market and the ever-changing economic scenario make it increasingly difficult for investors to select the right investment avenues in the right proportion.
Considering that each of the investment options carries some risk and that there is a direct relationship between risk and reward, it is vital to choose wisely. Therefore, the key is to invest in a manner that allows you to potentially lower your investment risk and enhance your chances to achieve your varied financial goals. All of us have certain financial goals and also have a certain tolerance for risk when it comes to investing our money. Of course, asset allocation doesn’t always mean the same thing for every investor. For example, some believe that large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap growth stocks and value stocks are different asset classes. The fact, however, is that these are all a part of the same asset class i.e. equity.
The objective of dividing securities into an asset classes is to design an optimal portfolio. In other words, the objective is to find out an ideal combination that is expected to generate a higher ratio of return to risk. For an asset allocation strategy to be successful, it must be flexible enough to accommodate the changes in one’s financial circumstances as well as the changes in the economic cycle. It is important because economic environment has a direct impact on the behaviour of the financial markets. Before deciding as to how you can put your asset allocation strategy to work, it is important to understand how diversification works hand-in-hand with asset allocation.
When you diversify your investments, you minimise the chances of suffering from what is known as ‘single-security risk’, or the risk that your investment will fluctuate widely in value with the price of one holding. It is important to keep certain key points in mind while deciding on the asset allocation for your portfolio and practicing it over a period of time. Some of these are:
[PAGE BREAK]
The key ingredients should be your time horizon, investment goals, and risk tolerance. Your time horizon is the expected number of months or years you will be investing to achieve your financial goals. If you have a longer time horizon, you may feel more comfortable investing in a riskier but potentially better investment option because you will have time on hand to wait out slow economic cycles as well as inevitable volatile periods. For example, while investing for your retirement, you can afford to put a greater percentage of assets in equities as you would generally have many years until you reach that stage. Risk tolerance is your ability and willingness to lose a part of your original investment during short-term market movements in exchange for greater potential returns.
As prices of different types of assets do not move in tandem, a combination of different asset classes helps in managing the market risk efficiently. In fact, various studies have shown that asset allocation is the most important factor in determining returns from investing. However, one needs to rebalance the asset allocation from time to time i.e. to bring the current allocation level back to the original asset allocation level to maintain the balance in the portfolio. Besides, one has to find out ways to improve returns over the investment period as well as to balance the risks. One such strategy could be to invest income generated by the debt portfolio into equities and take the profits out of the equity portfolio and invest the same into income generating securities. If you do this from time to time, you can capture both ends of the investment spectrum.
As your investment time frame and goals change, so might your asset allocation. Be prepared to re-evaluate your asset allocation periodically. Some of the events that would prompt you to do so could be the education of your children, buying a house or retirement. However, the most important factor is to get started. Remember, it is never too late to get started and it’s never too late to revamp the asset allocation plan. A key element for the success of an asset allocation is to adopt the right strategy for implementing it. Once the strategy is in place, the focus has to be on selecting the most appropriate instruments. The key considerations while selecting the instruments have to be flexibility, transparency, tax efficiency, and liquidity.