Do Not Become Fund Collector

Ali On Content / 16 Feb 2009


Q. At present I have SIP in following funds:
1)  Reliance Growth Fund Rs. 1000 (15 years)
2)  Reliance Vision  Fund Rs. 1000 (15 years)
3) Birla Sunlife Frontline Equity Fund   Rs. 1000 (20 Years)
4)  SBI Tax Saver Fund Rs. 1000 (5 years - 3 years balance)
5)  Sundaram Select Focus  Rs. 500  (2 years -1.5 years balance)
6)  Sundaram Tax Saver Rs. 500 (2 years - 1.5 Years balance)

Following are the details of completed SIPs:
1)  Reliance Equity Opportunity Fund –Lump sum Rs. 10000 ( 31.03.2005)
2)  SBI Midcap Fund – Lump sum Rs. 5000  (31.05.2005)
3)  Fidelity Equity Fund - SIP (Rs 1000*6) (NFO)
4)  SBI Multicap Fund –Lump sum Rs. 500 (NFO)
5)  Kotak Tax Saver - SIP (Rs. 500*36) (NFO)
6)  Birla Sunlife Top 100- SIP ( RS. 1000*6) (NFO)
7)  SBI Contra Fund - SIP (RS. 500*24) (Sep'06 T0  Sep'08)
8)  SBI Global Fund - SIP (RS. 500*24) (Sep'06 TO Sep'08)
9)  Sundaram Midcap Fund -SIP (RS. 500*24)  (Nov'06 TO Nov'08)
10)  ICICI Infrastructure Fund - SIP (Rs. 1000*6) (NFO)
11) HDFC Multi-Cap Fund -SIP (RS. 1000*36)  (Nov'05 TO Nov'08)
12) ICICI Power Fund -SIP (RS. 1000*24)  (Nov'05 TO Nov'07)
13) ICICI Tax Saver Fund –Lump sum (Rs. 10000)  3 years complete
14) Reliance Tax Saver – Lump sum (Rs. 10000)  3 years complete
15) Reliance Diversified Power Sector Fund – Lump sum   Rs. 10000 ( July'07)

Now, I am planning start new SIP for long term in any of following two funds -  
1) Birla Sunlife Dividend Yield
2) HDFC Growth Fund
3) Reliance Tax Saver
4) Kotak 30[PAGE BREAK]

You are requested to advice me on
1) In which fund should I start SIPs. 
2) Whether I should discontinue any current SIP. 
3) Whether I should switch over from mutual funds where I have already made investment. 

You are also requested to mention the funds in which to should switch over. I am 28 years old, salaried employee, married and have a kid of 18 months.


- Shaishav Shah, On Email

A. All you have to do is add 3 more funds to your portfolio, and you will have one for every year of your life! On a more serious note, please do not aim to become a fund collector – being an investor is hard enough. Most of the funds in your current SIP list are fit to be weeded out, in my view. Another observation is that there are just too many mid cap  oriented funds in the list of current funds. You see, not only are they more volatile (meaning, unpredictable large swings), in the current environment they have become fundamen-tally more risky. Smaller companies, in general, have a lesser strength to withstand this downturn. Large companies, due to their size, have greater resources to go through the down-turn. Hence one may see more small and medium sized companies suffering from the lack of credit and contraction in turnover. The tax saver funds take advantage of their lock in clauses and include more mid cap stocks, because over a longer period their share value could jump more than a large established company. So in any case you have a large dose of mid caps. Of your list of 15, I would retain only Fidelity Equity, Sundaram Select Mid Cap, Pru Infrastructure and the Power Sector Fund.  Birla Sunlife Dividend Yield Plan is a low return – low volatility scheme. Compared to other equity funds, this has had a lower standard deviation. HDFC Growth is a reasonable fund, with large cap orientation. Kotak 30 has also been doing reasonably well. Funds I would like to have are DSP Blackrock Top 100, Sundaram Select Focus, Franklin Prima Plus and IDFC Equity. I do hope that you are also saving money in income funds and bank deposits apart from equity funds!

If you want to stay updated with the share market news today, keep a close watch on the indian stock market today with real time movements like sensex today live and overall stock market today trends. Investors tracking ipo allotment status, ipo news today, or the latest ipo india can also follow daily updates along with bse share price live data. Whether you are learning how to invest in stock market in india, preparing for a market crash today, or searching for the best stocks to buy in india, insights on top gainers today india, top losers today india, trending stocks india and long term stocks india help in making informed investment decisions.