HDFC Mid Cap Fund vs Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund: Which Scheme Comes Out Ahead?

HDFC Mid Cap Fund vs Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund: Which Scheme Comes Out Ahead?

HDFC Mid Cap Fund and Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund have both delivered strong long-term returns, but recent performance, portfolio strategy and risk profile reveal important differences that every investor should know before investing.

Key Takeaways

Mid cap Mutual Funds have become a popular choice among investors looking for higher long-term growth than large cap funds without taking on the higher risk associated with small cap schemes. These funds invest primarily in medium-sized companies that are in the growth stage of their business journey.

These funds are equity schemes that invest at least 65 per cent of their assets in mid cap companies, as defined by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI). These companies are ranked between 101 and 250 based on their full market capitalisation.

Looking for Quality Mid-Cap Growth Opportunities?
Explore DSIJ’s Mid Bridge - a research-driven service focused on fundamentally strong mid-cap companies with robust business models and long-term growth potential.
Download Free Service Brochure

Like any equity investment, mid cap funds can be volatile in the short term. They are generally better suited for investors with a long investment horizon and the ability to withstand market fluctuations.

Who should invest in mid cap funds?

Mid cap mutual funds may be suitable for investors who:

  • Have an investment horizon of at least five to seven years.
  • Are seeking long-term capital appreciation.
  • Can tolerate moderate to high market volatility.
  • Want to diversify their equity portfolio beyond large cap funds.

Among the most tracked schemes in this category are HDFC Mid Cap Fund and Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund. While both have built strong long-term track records, they differ in terms of returns across different periods, portfolio composition and fund size.

HDFC Mid Cap Fund vs Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund

Fund overview

Particulars

HDFC Mid Cap Fund

Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund

Category

Equity – Mid Cap

Equity – Mid Cap

Fund age

19 years 2 months

30 years 10 months

Fund size

Rs 1,00,858 crore

Rs 49,169 crore

Return comparison

Time period

HDFC Mid Cap Fund

Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund

3 months

6.70 per cent

4.12 per cent

6 months

3.79 per cent

6.77 per cent

1 year

9.46 per cent

10.22 per cent

3 years (annualised)

19.62 per cent

20.91 per cent

5 years (annualised)

19.41 per cent

18.54 per cent

The comparison shows that leadership changes depending on the investment period.

HDFC Mid Cap Fund has delivered stronger returns over the past three months and five years. Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund, on the other hand, has outperformed over the six-month, one-year and three-year periods.

Portfolio comparison

Top sector allocation

HDFC Mid Cap Fund

Allocation

Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund

Allocation

Financial

23.70 per cent

Financial

20.74 per cent

Healthcare

14.84 per cent

Services

19.07 per cent

Automobile

8.96 per cent

Healthcare

11.67 per cent

Top five holdings

HDFC Mid Cap Fund

Weight

Nippon India Growth Mid Cap Fund

Weight

The Federal Bank Ltd

4.18 per cent

BSE Ltd

2.99 per cent

Max Financial Services Ltd

4.10 per cent

The Federal Bank Ltd

2.75 per cent

AU Small Finance Bank Ltd

4.08 per cent

Fortis Healthcare Ltd

2.66 per cent

Balkrishna Industries Ltd

3.10 per cent

AU Small Finance Bank Ltd

2.65 per cent

Fortis Healthcare Ltd

3.07 per cent

Bharat Forge Ltd

2.37 per cent

Returns are important, but not the only factor

Historical returns are one of the first metrics investors look at while comparing mutual funds. However, experts believe they should not be the only factor influencing an investment decision, as past performance does not guarantee future returns.

Before investing, investors should also evaluate:

  • Risk-adjusted returns.
  • Portfolio diversification and stock concentration.
  • Fund manager's investment approach and track record.
  • Expense ratio.
  • Portfolio turnover.
  • Consistency across different market cycles.
  • Whether the scheme matches their financial goals and risk appetite.

Looking at these factors together provides a more balanced view of a fund's long-term potential.

Also Read - Top 3 Mid Cap Mutual Funds That Outperformed Over 5 Years

Disclaimer: The article is for informational purposes only and not investment advice.